Comparison
Best Wheel Cleaners 2025: A Chemistry-Based Comparison
We analyzed the Safety Data Sheets of three popular wheel cleaners to compare their actual formulations - not marketing claims. Here's what the chemistry tells us.
Quick Verdict
Best for Heavy Soiling
P&S Brake Buster
pH 12.5 alkaline power
Safest for Coated Wheels
Adams Deep Wheel Cleaner
pH 7 neutral chelation
Best Value
P&S Brake Buster
$0.19/oz at 5 gallon
Three Different Approaches to Wheel Cleaning
These three wheel cleaners represent fundamentally different chemical strategies for the same job. Understanding these differences helps you choose the right product for your specific wheels and contamination level.
Alkaline (P&S)
High pH (12.5) breaks down organic contamination through saponification. Aggressive but effective on heavy brake dust.
Unknown (Chemical Guys)
pH not disclosed. Proprietary formulation makes objective comparison difficult. Transparency concerns.
Chelation (Adams)
Neutral pH (7) with thioglycolate chelating agents. Binds to iron particles without aggressive pH. Safest approach.
Head-to-Head Comparison
| Metric | Brake BusterP&S | Diablo GelChemical Guys | Deep Wheel CleanerAdam's Polishes |
|---|---|---|---|
| pH Level | 12.5 | N/D | 7 |
| Cleaning Mechanism | High pH alkaline cleaning saponifies oils and brake dust, while triple surfactant system emulsifies and lifts contaminants. EDTA chelates metal ions and hard water minerals. | not disclosed | thioglycolate chelation |
| Signal Word | Warning | None | Warning |
| Transparency | Excellent | Limited | Excellent |
| Surfactant Count | 3 | 1 | 2 |
| Dilutable | Yes | Yes | No |
| Best Price/oz | $0.19 | $0.59 | $0.41 |
| Safe for Coated Wheels | ✓ Yes | Unknown | ✓ Yes |
Detailed Analysis
P&S Brake Buster uses high alkaline chemistry (pH 12.5 from sodium metasilicate) instead of acids or thioglycolates. The extreme pH saponifies oils and brake dust while a triple surfactant system (amphoteric + anionic + cationic) emulsifies and lifts contaminants. EDTA chelating agent binds metals and hard water minerals for enhanced cleaning in any water condition.
Strengths
- ✓pH 12.5 - extreme alkaline approach (vs thioglycolate or acidic)
- ✓Triple surfactant system for broad cleaning spectrum
- ✓EDTA chelating for hard water performance
- ✓Acid-free - safe for all wheel finishes
Considerations
- •High pH requires PPE (gloves, eye protection)
- •May strip wax and sealant from surfaces
- •Not recommended for anodized aluminum
- •No color-change indicator (can't see when it's working)
$0.19/oz (5_gallon)
pH-balanced, non-caustic formula prioritizing safety over aggressive cleaning power. Uses anionic surfactant (Sodium C14-16 Olefin Sulfonate) for foaming and cleaning, combined with undisclosed chelating agent. 'Oxygen-infused' marketing suggests aeration or peroxide-based cleaning enhancement, but specific mechanism not disclosed.
Strengths
- ✓pH-balanced and non-caustic (safe for frequent use)
- ✓Safe for all wheel finishes including matte
- ✓Non-hazardous per OSHA standards
- ✓Available as concentrate and RTU
Considerations
- •Very low ingredient transparency - most components withheld
- •No pH value disclosed despite 'pH-balanced' claims
- •No dilution ratios provided for concentrate
- •Isothiazolinone preservatives (can cause sensitization in some users)
$0.59/oz (1_gallon)
Adams uses iron remover chemistry (thioglycolate chelation) in a wheel cleaner. pH 6-8 (near neutral) with (2-hydroxyethyl)ammonium mercaptoacetate (1-5%) as primary active ingredient. This is the same chelating agent used in iron removers, providing color-changing feedback as it reacts with iron particles. Dual surfactant system (cationic + nonionic) provides cleaning power while chelation removes iron and brake dust. Safe for all wheel finishes due to neutral pH. Similar approach to Armour Detail Supply Wheel Cleaner.
Strengths
- ✓ONLY chelation-based wheel cleaner analyzed (vs alkaline or acidic)
- ✓Near neutral pH (6-8) - safest for delicate finishes
- ✓Uses iron remover chemistry for brake dust removal
- ✓100% ingredient transparency - best in class
Considerations
- •Contains endocrine disruptor (≥0.1%)
- •Contains fragrance allergens (coumarin, d-limonene)
- •Contains phthalates (diethyl phthalate in fragrance)
- •May cause allergic skin reaction
$0.41/oz (5gal)
The Transparency Gap
One of the most significant findings in this comparison is the difference in ingredient disclosure. P&S and Adams both provide complete ingredient lists with CAS numbers and concentration ranges. Chemical Guys withholds significant formulation details, making objective comparison difficult.
This matters because consumers deserve to know what chemicals they're spraying on their vehicles and being exposed to. Transparency should be the norm, not the exception.
The Bottom Line
Choose P&S Brake Buster if you have heavily soiled wheels, uncoated finishes, or need maximum cleaning power at the best price.
Choose Adams Deep Wheel Cleaner if you have coated wheels (ceramic, powder coat), delicate finishes, or prioritize the safest possible chemistry.
Chemical Guys Diablo Gel remains difficult to fully evaluate due to incomplete ingredient disclosure. If transparency matters to you, consider the alternatives.
Want to see the full data?